Wisdom for Rookie Youth Pastors: Getting Rid of Your Preconceived Notions
By Josh Fuentes
Restored from the YouthMin archive.

Being a youth pastor is one of the greatest jobs in the world. Being able to declare the Gospel to students and see how Christ transforms their lives is what it’s all about. There’s nothing that sets a fire in me more than seeing students live out their faith. I’m pretty sure all of you would agree with me. In fact, I’m 100% sure that’s one of the main reasons why you’re going into youth ministry.
The odds are you were involved in a youth group, and probably were a leader, too. I’m sure during this time, you thought, “My youth pastor is so awesome. He has the best job in the world. All he does is hangout with teenagers, eat pizza, and share Jesus with everybody. I could so do that!” If so, then you’re in for a rude awakening when you start your first youth pastor position.
Like every youth pastor, who was a rookie like you, we all had this idea we were going to change the world. Maybe not change the world, but at least lead their students to start the next great awakening within their church. So you start your first youth pastor position, and guess what? No world changers, no great awakenings, and instead, you get upset parents, a pastor who doesn’t get it, and a stuck in their ways church. This is not what you signed up for. What happened?
I am completely convinced the reason why most rookie youth pastors struggle is because they have preconceived notions about youth ministry. Don’t feel bad, it’s not your fault. The problem is that when you were a student, small group leader, or even an intern in a youth ministry, all you were exposed to were the main events–the worship service, small groups, fellowships, and mission trips. All you saw was the glamour side of youth ministry and not the day-in-day-out. When this happens we end up constructing a gross misrepresentation of youth ministry, and when we’re finally faced with reality, our worlds come tumbling down.
Yet, this doesn’t have to be. You can overcome your preconceived notions about youth ministry, and start off right in your first position. Here are 3 realities to help you get rid of your preconceived notions.
Student ministry is more than just students
Yes, our target audience is students, but if you’re spending all of your time with them, you’re doing it wrong .
If you’re going to make it as a student minister, you’re going to need to invest in volunteers and parents. Your volunteers are either teaching bible studies or helping you put together events. These people love students, and your ability to touch every student in your youth group is through your volunteer team. On the other hand, parents are the spiritual leaders of their household. If you really want to see students transformed by the Gospel, minister to their parents, because they are the number one influence in your students lives, not you. I will have more to share about how to minister to parents in a later post.
You are the low man on the totem pole
If you go into your first student ministry position with guns blazing, you’ll be out of a job before you know it. Why is that? Two reasons. First, your position in the church. When it comes to staff priority, you’re at the bottom of the barrel, because the group you minister to is a minority in the church. The pastor in over the entire congregation, the music minister leads worship for the entire congregation, the children’s minister works with infancy to 5th or 6th grade, and the custodians have to clean up after the entire church. You work with a small group for only 5 to 6 years.
The second reason is because you have not built any credibility. Your staff, parents, volunteers, and students have no idea who you are. This also puts you at the bottom of the barrel. Yet, the longer you stay and the more relationships you build, will create trust between all of these groups. Recognizing, and accepting your status, will allow you to minister clearly and see other people’s perspective. Yes being the low man can suck, but Christianity was never about position either.
You will be burned
The old saying goes, “Church would be great, if it weren’t for all the people.” For some odd reason we have this perfect church in our heads where everything works great. You and I know this is not true because the Church is made up of people, and we’re all sinners in recovery. We don’t always get our faith right, and because of it, we can do some pretty awful stuff to each other. This means you will be burned. You will have people say and do some of the most outrageous thing to you and your family. This is part of the job, and there’s no getting around this. It will eventually happen to you, but if you recognize and prepare for it, you’ll be a lot better off when it happens.
In the end, it is your job to recognize what you bring with you to your ministry. We all bring the good, the bad, and the ugly, and we are better off when we do some soul searching to find out the root cause. Talk to veteran youth pastors, and ask them about their preconceived thoughts to help you come to terms with what you’re getting into. More importantly, pray for God to search your heart, so you can have the proper attitude towards student ministry.
For veterans, what else would you add to this list?
What can we do to help our students see more than the glamour side of student ministry?