Why We Don’t Do Gross Games in Youth Group
By Keith Parker
Restored from the YouthMin archive.
“Pickled pigs feet.” “Blended Happy Meals.” “Live goldfish.” “Cat food.” What do these things have in common, you might ask. They are all the answer to a recent question in our YouthMin Facebook group – “What is something really gross that you have had a kid eat as a challenge during a game?”
Having grown up in youth group and being a Youth Minister now for over 16 years, I’ve seen my fair share of up-front gross games. I will even say that I have been the perpetrator of a few of these games in my early career. But as I have grown older, wiser (jury is still out on that one), and had kids of my own, I have walked away from the “gross game” trend. This post is not intended to be judgmental or accusatory, but instead to share with you the deliberate reasons To ensure that we are fair and impartial, we’ve asked Brian Lucas to write a post from the opposite perspective, which you can read HERE .
So here are a few reasons why we avoid gross games in our youth ministry:
1. Potential Embarrassment / Alienation
Early on in my ministry at Hazelwood, my wife got called to the front of a multi-church retreat by the game leader. I didn’t know what was going to take place, and neither did she. To make a long story short, my wife ended up in tears as the “victim” of a completely innocent game. The goal wasn’t embarrassment or ridicule, but that was the result.
When we play gross games in youth group, there is no doubt lots of energy in the room. On a surface level, these games seem to create a fun atmosphere, which I’m fairly certain is the goal. Most Youth Ministers I know won’t play a gross game unless someone volunteers, which is a wise move. But even if 90% of your students think that gross games are hilarious, there is a strong chance that at least one student is sitting in the back of the room disgusted, disengaged, and petrified that they might someday be called upon and pressured into participating in such a game.
To me, this risk is far too great for a cheap laugh and a couple minutes of energy. There are other “fun” activities that we can lead that don’t have the potential of alienation and embarrassment. I’ll stick with those options. ( Note: if you need some great game ideas, check out the Games section on our site )
2. Safety / Perception
Lets face it – when it comes to parents and church leaders, perception matters. I want people in our church and our community to view our youth ministry as a safe place where students are accepted, loved, and treated with grace and kindness.
I believe that gross games undermine the “safe place” perception that we are seeking. When a student shows up to youth group and I make them eat cat food or live crickets or worms or whatever, the perception of loving and caring for students takes a solid kick in the teeth.
We’ve all experienced this at some point: We get back from an amazing weekend retreat with awesome worship, great truth, and growing relationships. When the students get off the bus, they are greeted by their parents, who inevitably ask, “How was the weekend?” We cringe as we hear the student respond, “It was awesome, Billy ______________ ( fill in the blank with “got eaten by a bear,” “threw up in his shoe,” “broke his femur,” etc. ). Students will often share these crazy moments with those who entrust them to our care. I think we need to take that very seriously, and causing a student to hurl in front of their peers does not promote a “safe” environment.
3. Lack of Purpose
Why? In my opinion, that’s probably the most important question we can ask in ministry. What is the purpose behind this thing I’m about to do or say? When it comes to gross games, I just think they are completely outside the purpose of youth ministry. There is no Kingdom benefit, no positive relational movement, and no real reason for making a student eat Spam in front of their peers.
I know, I know…I’m a stick-in-the-mud, a wet blanket, and a fuddy duddy. Most who play gross games would say they do it for “fun.” Great. I think youth group should be fun. But I think there are a million other ways to create a fun environment without the risks that gross games pose. Be original. Be different. Be intentional.
4. The Mess
Since the dawn of time, Youth Ministers and Facilities Managers have lived at odds. Many youth ministries get a reputation for being loud, messy, and destructive. Call me crazy, but I think it’s time to change the landscape. I want our Facilities Manager (Ed Wilkes, greatest guy alive) to be the biggest fan of our youth ministry, and part of that starts with how we treat the facility we’ve been entrusted with.
Many times, the gross games I hear about in youth group cause quite a mess. Whether it’s a disgusting item that’s been blended up or puke from a student who has eaten something gross, I certainly don’t want to be cleaning that up, and I don’t expect someone else to clean it up either. While many Youth Ministers plan ahead and use a tarp or trash cans to stave off the mess, the potential for the mop bucket still exists. I don’t mind cleaning up after the students leave my house after LifeGroups, and I don’t mind gathering the wet robes after a baptism. But cleaning up after a gross game seems like a much lesser work, and when combined with the other reasons mentioned, it’s just not worth it in my opinion.
5. Time Management / Waste
If you’re in ministry, you know time is a precious commodity. Not only our own personal time that is spent in preparation for ministry activities, but also the amount of time we get with students in general. We may see a core student for 2-3 hours a week at most, and fringe students far less. I want our time together to be fun, intentional, meaningful, and Christ-centered. I’m not saying that you should never play a game or do something silly to up the “fun factor,” but again, when you factor in all the risk, embarrassment, mess, and more, this doesn’t feel like a great way to spend our time.
I’m eager to hear from some of you. Do you play gross games in your ministry? Why or why not? What reasons for or against would you add to your list? Looking forward to the conversation. Keep reaching students for Jesus, and keep being extraordinary!


