The Inner Battle: Persevering Through Staff Turmoil

By Keith Parker

Restored from the YouthMin archive.

A narrow forest trail surrounded by ferns.
Photo: K8 / Unsplash

Teamwork can be one of the most amazing and powerful forces on the planet. When a team is functioning well, working together toward a singular goal, it can be a thing of beauty. I remember watching the Chicago Bulls in the 1990s, arguably the best basketball team in history. While Michael Jordan was obviously the superstar of that team, every player on that team did his part. Scottie Pippen was the second scorer and playmaker. Dennis Rodman was the rebounder and the defensive “energy guy.” Steve Kerr was the sharpshooter. Luc Longley was there to foul Shaq. Every player did his part, and it was awesome.

Teamwork, however, can also be a source of great frustration and bitterness. In ministry, staff turmoil can often lead to resentment, questioning your calling, silo ministry, and apathy. Whether you are part of a large staff with multiple other ministers or a small staff with only a couple people, the chances are good that you will eventually experience staff turmoil on some level.

So how can we minimize the damage done by these staff conflicts? How can we persevere through tough times with our teammates? Here are a few ideas:

1. Choose your battles

We are passionate about our ministries, which is a great thing. Sometimes, however, our passion can lead us to be overly sensitive and protective of our areas of ministry. When we become territorial, conflict is right around the corner. In my experience, staff conflict often occurs when my ministry overlaps with another.

When something gets me fired up, I’ve started asking myself a few questions as I discern whether or not to make it a “thing.” Here are a few of the questions I ask:

Was the offense done on purpose?

Was there malicious intent?

Were my ministry or my students hurt?

Are there ongoing Kingdom consequences?

If the answer to these questions is “no,” then I usually overlook it and move forward. It is important to choose your battles as you interact with other staff.

2. See the big picture

It can be very easy to fall into the trap of believing that your ministry is the most important and the most successful, and therefore entitled to the prime treatment in every instance. This perspective is arrogant, narrow, unbiblical, and detrimental to the local church. Serving in the local church alongside other staff members requires you to see the bigger picture. It requires you to see other ministries as equally important and equally crucial.

When we begin to see the big picture, it changes how we do ministry, how we interact with our fellow staff members, and how we operate as a team. The goal is to have a healthy church, not just a healthy youth ministry. Your youth ministry will not succeed with a terrible ministry to children, and your discipleship ministry falls apart if the youth ministry is struggling. See the big picture.

3. Be biblical

When confrontation DOES occur (and it will) with another staff member, it is important to be biblical in your approach. Remember Matthew 18 principles and approach staff conflict accordingly. Speak to them one on one. Involve another staff member if things don’t change.

Seek reconciliation and not division. Humble yourself and put others first. Pray for the staff member and try to see things from their perspective. As Ephesians 5:21 says, “Submit to one another out of reverence for Christ.” Being biblical in your approach will give you the best opportunity for resolution and reconciliation.

4. Don’t make excuses

One of the hardest things about staff turmoil is the toll it can take on your own work ethic. When you are part of a team that is clicking, it is easy to work hard, to bring maximum effort, and to work alongside your teammates for the good of the whole Body. But when things are out of sync, it affects everything. Staff turmoil can easily lead to excuses, bitterness, and eventually apathy.

“Why should I even try? They will just undermine my efforts.”

“Why should I put in my hours at the office when they don’t?”

“Why should I put away the mess I made? They wouldn’t do it for me!”

“Why go the extra mile when it’s not appreciated?”

If any of these sound familiar, repent and change your attitude! Staff conflict should never be an excuse for apathy or laziness.

5. Pray for unity

I’ve found this simple fact to be true: it’s REALLY difficult to hate the people you pray for. When you are praying for someone earnestly and sincerely, it is very difficult to resent them, despise them, or wish terrible things upon them to the thousandth generation (if it’s real bad). When you have staff turmoil or conflict, up your prayer life to match. Pray for your fellow teammates by name. Lift up their ministries to the Lord regularly. Even better, pray WITH your teammates. Pray that God will bring unity in the midst of struggle.

These are just a few things I remind myself to do whenever staff turmoil or conflict pop up. If you don’t seek resolution, staff conflict can be one of the quickest paths to burnout and bitterness. How do you deal with conflict among your staff? I’d love to hear your thoughts.

Resources for your next gathering

Give your volunteers useful feedback

Prepare a clear conversation and agree on a practical next step.

Essentials — Youth Pastor Co

For a future teaching series, explore four weeks on believing, belonging, becoming, and building into others.