The Inner Battle: Overcoming Apathetic Students
By Keith Parker
Restored from the YouthMin archive.
Having been a Youth Minister for over 15 years now, I think I have probably heard every excuse in the book for why a student wouldn’t be attending youth group or a summer trip.
“I have sports.”
“I have band.”
“I have homework.”
“My mom doesn’t want to drive me.”
“It just doesn’t seem like fun.”
“I was asleep.”
“It’s just not deep enough for me.”
“________________ will be there and that would be awkward.”
“I’m not getting anything out of it.”
“It’s too early.”
“It’s too late.”
“I’m grounded.”
“I forgot.”
“I don’t think anyone is going.”
I could probably keep going, but I think you get the idea. We have all dealt with apathetic students in our ministries. All of us have felt the frustration of low attendance, students being “checked out,” disappearing students, families that seem to always choose sports over everything else, and students slipping through the cracks. So how do we overcome the frustration of apathetic students? How do we ensure that low attendance doesn’t become resentment and bitterness? How do we stay positive when apathy seems to rule the day? When you find yourself discouraged by apathetic students, here are a few truths to remember.
1. You can’t control everything
I know you do your best to plan things in advance, to communicate events and programs early, and to encourage students to be involved. No matter how well you plan, however, you simply cannot control every factor that affects your students. Remember that your students may have a tough home life where getting a ride to church is like World War 3. Remember that your students may be under immense pressure from their coaches, teachers, and parents. Remember that you can’t control when the history teacher dumps a huge project on your students. No matter how hard you try, you can’t control all the external factors that weigh on your students. Recognize it, come to terms with it, and stop worrying about it. No need to be a slave to the things you can’t control, right?
2. Focus on the ones who ARE involved
We recently went on a mission trip to Pennsylvania, and we took the smallest group of students I’ve ever taken anywhere (in 14 years). Initially, that frustrated me. Why were students choosing vacations and other Spring Break activities instead of our mission trip? But after a while, I decided to focus all my attention on the ones who DID want to come. We made a deliberate effort as a leadership team to connect deeply with each student, to ask some pressing questions about faith and life as we worked together, and to grow as a group through meaningful Bible study. It ended up being a great trip instead of a frustration.
Though apathetic students can take the wind out of our sails, we can stave off frustration by focusing our attention on the ones who DO want to be involved. Place your attention squarely on the students who crave Jesus and invest your time and energy there. You’ll be more fulfilled, and you’ll begin to see their passion infect others.
3. God always wants your best
So often, it becomes easy to let apathetic students affect our mood and, in turn, our performance as leaders. We begin to think things like, “Well, they don’t care, so why should I?” Don’t let their apathy affect God’s calling on your life.
Colossians 3:17 reminds us “whatever you do, whether in word or deed, do it all in the name of the Lord Jesus, giving thanks to God the Father through him.” No matter how many students show up or how passionate they are, you have been called to teach, disciple, mentor, and love students with everything you’ve got. Strive for excellence no matter how your students respond. Let your passion spill out of everything you do, and you’ll see results. But remember, the most important results are spiritual, not numerical.
4. Prayer works
I know this goes without saying, but I’ll say it anyway. Pray for your students. Pray for your heart. Pray for passion. Pray for persistence. Pray for life change in your students. Pray for your messages to cut to the heart. Pray for direction. Pray for wisdom. Pray for your church. Pray for your adult leaders. Pray without ceasing, and your heart will follow.
How do you overcome apathetic students and avoid frustration and burnout?