The Gap In My Ministry
By Austin Walker
Restored from the YouthMin archive.

Part 1 of a Gospel and Students series.
I by no means claim to be an expert in student ministry. I’ve got 5 years of student ministry under my belt and still feel green. That being said, I’ve started to notice a gap, a lack, in the lives of students. In the past two years, I’ve been able to baptize about 15 or 20 students, some of whom grew up in church, accepted Christ years before, and just now had it “click” in their minds or hearts. Others have no prior church experience and accepted him sometimes days before their baptism.
Each time I baptize a student, I sit down, one on one, and process through a few things . I want them to tell me their story, including how they accepted Christ. This lets them process in their own mind as opposed to saying, “Tell me the time you met Jesus.” After that, I say something along the lines of, “So, I’m going to ask you a couple questions. But I’m going to act like I know nothing about Jesus , God, or anything, okay? Here we go, ‘You’re getting baptized, why?’”
I continue to prod, letting them flesh out their story, and essentially trying to get them to articulate the message of the gospel .
In doing that, I’ve noticed a huge flaw in my student ministry, in the churches some of them have come from, and potentially in your student ministry.
Some of the students who “get it” more than others can make it to, “Jesus died for my sins.” After that, there are some MAJOR questions they can’t articulate.
Why does sin mean you have to die? They often don’t understand the contrast between God’s holiness and perfect justice. The fact that sin spits in the face of a God who is perfect and just hasn’t crossed their mind. (Ps 51:5, Rom 5:12-17, 1 Cor 15:21-22, Eph 2:3). It is impossible to appease God’s wrath (Rom 1:18, 2:5-8) and reconcile humankind’s relationship with the Creator (Rom 3:10-20). THAT is why we need the Gospel.
What does Jesus dying on the cross have anything to do with me? Students have problems connecting the dots of justification and imputed righteousness. Justification is described a little more below. Imputed righteousness means that Christ’s holiness is given to us. The tandem of justification and imputed righteousness, as I describe it to students, means we are wearing clothes totally filthy with life. Justification is Christ taking our filthy clothes, imputed righteousness is him giving us HIS flawless clothes in return. (1 Cor 1:30, Phil 3:9).
So when I “accept Jesus,” what happens? Not only is imputed righteousness a concept they haven’t walked through, but often students assume that the sins they ask forgiveness for are swept under the rug (justification), as if the account is just zero’d out. It’s an amazing moment to see the students start to grasp that their account is paid down, not zero’d out. (Rom 4:24-25, 5:9, 1 Cor 6:11, 15:3, 2 Cor 5:15, Gal 2:15-16, Heb 9:15-28). Sometimes, I list OT practices as a precedent to set up the need for Jesus (Lev 9:7, 16:30, 17:11).
The ultimate debt that could not be paid was atoned for by the One who owed nothing, motivated by eternal love and enduring grace. (1 Tim 2:5, Titus 3:7)
Ultimately, it comes down to this… students know they’ve sinned and can’t be with God if they have sin. They know “accepting Jesus into their hearts” gives them forgiveness of sins and a hope for the future. But they don’t know why and they don’t know how.
My fear?
Without the how , students can’t provide a cogent argument or reasonable explanation of their faith to their friends. They know the bullet points, but not the process.
Without the why , there’s no reason to see value in Christ’s work on the cross as compared to any other means of “salvation.”
I don’t like making blanket statements, so hear me say this…this is not the case for all of my students, and it may not be the case for any of your students. But it is the case for some students. After walking through this with them, I still baptize them and encourage them, but continue to try and equip them moving forward
Look at your ministry and your students, would you say they know the how and why of Christ’s death?
As a side note, I try and give every student that gets baptized (newfound faith or new proclamation of existing faith) a copy of NEW by Andy Blanks. I tell them a lot of this will seem basic, especially if they’ve grown up in church, but it will help connect a lot of dots and answer a lot of questions. In addition, they get a copy of Bible Study , to show them HOW to actually read Scripture well.