How To Keep Your Youth Ministry Small

By Kolby Milton

Restored from the YouthMin archive.

Eight years ago I started at a small church with a small youth ministry. I remember being terrified. I had no idea what I was doing…even after 3 years of an internship, and 5+ years of school. Bible college and seminary could never prepare me for what being a pastor was. To be honest, it was a horrible year and a half start. It was rocky, and I wasn’t sure I was going to make it. Once I got into the groove of ministry, I quickly realized that growing any size of youth ministry will have it’s challenges, but its worth it. It’s worth it because we want to see student’s lives transformed by God.

Though there is no guaranteed recipe for how to grow a youth ministry, Here are a few things I learned along the way that will hinder the growth of your youth ministry.

Make it all about you.

Everything you do in ministry is ego building. Every instagram, facebook post, tweet, shows how awesome you are in youth ministry. You preach more passionately about your life, and the things you have done, than Jesus’ life. You don’t have time for real relationships because you are trying to become the best youth pastor ever.

Don’t make ministry all about you. Make it about Jesus. Stop getting in the way.

Its all about the numbers.

You throw around numbers like you are the king of the world. I struggle when I am around youth pastors and they throw numbers around. I know my numbers because I want to see growth happen, but I don’t what a number to be come the definition of success in my ministry. Also, stop sharing numbers on facebook. No one cares if you had 100 students out, or 50.

The teenagers that I work with need to know that they are more important than numbers. They are not just number 50 on my quest to be the worlds best youth pastor. There is a person there, who desperately needs Jesus as much as me. The students you serve need to know that you love them no matter what. That you might be the only person to show them how Jesus truly loves them. That is worth more that numbers.

(On a side note, I worry about the next generation of youth pastors and if all we do is quantify what we do as a youth ministry is by our numbers, we will never fix the problem. I try to be careful around my intern when it comes to numbers. I don’t want him to think ministry is all about “numbers”.)

How can you guard your heart and mind not to focus on the numbers this week?

You don’t trust anyone.

If you never bring people into your ministry that outshine you, you will never reach the students you need to reach. Stop being insecure about your leaders, and let them lead. The best part of trusting and passing things off to your leaders is that they will do things better than you!

I have been insecure in the past with leaders because I have worked with some of the best youth leaders. They are better at me in so many areas. It is easy to question your job because you are being out done by your leaders on a weekly basis. In those moments I meditate on Matthew 6:33, “But seek first the kingdom of God and his righteousness, and all these things will be added to you.” Looking back on those insecurities I am ashamed that I ever felt that way to some of my closest friends.

Some of my most successful moments are when I was able to fade into the background and let my adult and student leaders truly lead. I will always remember the moment when one of my adult leaders led a student to Christ on the way to his small group, when another leader led a intense prayer time at a camp retreat, and whenever I hear about leaders taking students out during the week one-on-one. Hopefully, you have some amazing leaders. It might be the time to trust them.

What is one thing you can pass off your full plate this week? How can you empower and enable a leader to use a gift that you could never use?

Your too busy for discipleship.

Being a disciple maker takes time. It takes being intentional. Who do you have in your life who calls you out on the things that matter? My wife asks me all the time if I have been in the office too much. She asks that question that hurts…because it is true. It is easy to get stuck behind a desk in the office. That isn’t what I am called to do. I am called to disciple students who disciple students.

Looking back on my last ministry the only thing I wish I did more of was hangout with students, leaders, and parents.

Who are 3 students this week you can make time for? How are you going to intentionally disciple them?

Those are a few things that will keep your youth ministry small. Looking back at your ministry what are some of the barriers that kept your ministry from growing?

Resources for your next gathering

Give your volunteers useful feedback

Prepare a clear conversation and agree on a practical next step.

Essentials — Youth Pastor Co

For a future teaching series, explore four weeks on believing, belonging, becoming, and building into others.