5 Backup Youth Group Games for When Plans Change

By Jeremy Smith

Restored from the YouthMin archive.

Keep five backup youth group games ready, with setup notes and rules for moments when you need a short activity or a change of plan.

Editorial update by YouthMin, September 30, 2026. Original article by Jeremy Smith; original publication date retained.

Prepare a small set of familiar games

A backup game is most useful when you already know how to explain it. Jeremy Smith’s list includes activities with different preparation needs: Mad Gabs uses phrase cards, Gargle Guess needs song prompts and cups, while Clumps and Simon Says mainly need your instructions.

Choose two options that fit your usual room. Keep any supplies together, and decide how you will end a round when it is time to move on.

Jeremy Smith’s five backup games

photo courtesy of lyon photography

Here are a list of a few games I keep in my back pocket when youth group ends too early and I need to occupy 5 or 10 minutes. All of these games require little to no setup and are a constant favorite with the teens. Because of this, none of these free games are ever formally added to the curriculum we use to not over play them and keep these games fresh and exciting.

Mad Gabs

This fun family game is a perfect youth ministry game in a box. It might be suggested tat you have your volunteers or self do a couple of the first ones so that students know it is okay to laugh when the person cannot guess it, but quickly students will step up to play.

Clumps

Start by instructing the entire group to stand in the center of the room. Tell them to move around at random, provide music. Call out a category for students to clump together (suggestions below). Everyone should then scramble to form “clumps” of likeness. When the clump is formed, sit on the floor. After all clumps have been formed, ask everyone to stand and mingle again.

Suggested Categories: Color of hair, favorite class, grade in school, favorite sport, age, branch of the military, school you attend, favorite music artist, type of footwear, color of eyes

Ultimate Simon Says

This is similar to Simon Says, but we do trickery. PLEASE LET THEM KNOW UP FRONT that it is possible that no one wins. Here are a list of good Simon Says ideas, but be safe and fun (don’t have them spin endlessly or do too many push-ups):

Run in place

Jump on one leg

Rub your belly and pat your head

High five your neighbor

Snort like a pig

Stand on one leg

Here are some ways to get them to lose:

If several people get out at one time, have the group scoot in. If they do so, they are out. (No Simon Says!)

Do a series of “Left/Right hand up/down” and imitate what they are supposed to do. After a few, tell them to raise a hand, but put up the wrong one. If they follow your example and not the command, they are out.

Speed Round: They must do the action quickly, meaning you have to watch all and still have the next thing for them to do. If they take too long to do something or do it wrong, they are out.

If someone “wins,” before you tell them they are the winner, offer them a high-five for doing so well. If they high five you, they loose

Knockdown

Have the students find a partner and stand 2-3 feet apart. Have them hold up their hands and try to slap hands to knock the other person off balance; they can only touch hands. The first person to move their feet loses. Once a person loses, they must sit down while the winners continue playing. The last person out is the winner.

Gargle Guess

Before this game starts, have all of the songs below on this sheet of paper. Tell the students that two of them from each team with the best singing voice to come forward. The next person up will draw one of the slips of paper and will have to have a Dixie cup full of water in their mouth. Then they will sing the song on the paper and their team guesses. If another team says it, they active team still get the points. Make sure the other teams are not distracting, or they could lose points. 2,500 for each one right within 30 seconds. (For the second round, it might be good to have a device with headphones to play the song for them to know how to sing it)

Mary Had A Little Lamb

Jesus Loves Me

Itsy Bitsy Spider

Humpty Dumpty

Justin Bieber – Baby

Bruno Mars – Just the Way You Are

Rebecca Black – Friday

Add a screen option to your plan

If a screen is already available, Which is Worse? Vol. 1 gives students paired choices and has them move to vote. Read the rules and preview a prompt before choosing it for your group. For a larger collection of activities, explore our team-building games guide .

Want a game you can preview first?

Get three complete games free , or browse the youth group games collection . Check the rules and supplies for the game you choose before adding it to your plan.

Resources for your next gathering

Youth group games from YouthMin

Compare game formats and preview the included files for your next gathering.

Essentials — Youth Pastor Co

For a future teaching series, explore four weeks on believing, belonging, becoming, and building into others.

Youth Group Games

Explore games for your next gathering. Read the rules, preview a round, and check the included files before choosing.

Explore youth group games