Dear Baby-Faced Youth Pastor,

By youthmin.org

Restored from the YouthMin archive.

A person writing in an open notebook.
Photo: Kaleidico / Unsplash

My name is Sam Pettersen, and I am a baby-faced youth pastor. Its not an opinion that I’m baby-faced; it’s been proven over and over again by parents and other adults.

This is not me at 18 years of ——- age; this is me as at 26

One time, I was waiting with a 7th grade student for his mom to come get him, and when she finally came she yelled out her car window “Does your little friend need a ride?” I let her know that my mommy was coming.

Another time a lady was praying for my health and ended her prayer like this, “And Lord just bless this man….child……” Yeah, she called me a man-child. She wasn’t sure if I was a man or a child, so she combined the two. Later she apologized and explained she didn’t know how old I was, which is why every person has nicknamed me The Man-Child.

I thought I grew up a little and looked a slightly older, but this past summer I took my middle school students to camp, and as we sat down for one of the main sessions, another youth pastor came over and told our group to move. I explained that we were here already. The youth pastor went on to explain that their group was larger, needed more space and I should go tell my youth pastor that our group should relocate… I don’t know who felt more awkward when I explained who I was. My students and volunteers enjoyed the moment though.

You Will Be Despised

I’ve come to terms with looking like a 16 year old, and not because of that weird thing people always say to young-looking 26 year olds: “Oh, but you’re gonna look so good when you’re 45.” That’s great and all, but I would rather be respected today instead of waiting 20 years. I’ve come to terms with looking young, because it’s challenged me to live my life to a higher standard. That standard is described by Paul in 1 Timothy 4:12

Let no one despise you for your youth, but set the believers an example in speech, in conduct, in love, in faith, in purity.

Here’s what Paul isn’t saying: “Timothy, you deserve respect, therefore people will respect you. Despite you being young or looking young, people are going to respect you. Why? Because I said so.”

I feel like I have to point that out because there are so many student workers that take this scripture and they treat it like a license to demand respect. “You can’t disrespect me! Paul said you can’t despise me for my youth!” Paul isn’t trying to give Timothy instant access to being respected. Paul is warning Timothy by saying, “You’re going to be despised because of your youth. People are not going to want to follow you or listen to you because you’re younger than them.” This is Paul’s warning to all of you baby-faced pastors as well. Your youthfulness is going to be used against you and your ministry.

Encouraging, right? But Paul continues with this: Set the believers an example in speech, in conduct, in love, in faith, in purity. Live your life in a way that turns people’s heads. Live a life with so much integrity that it causes the older generations to be convicted about their life choices. If you have other staff members that are older or above you in rank, challenge them with all humility.

Set the Example

I’ve known from the beginning that ministry would be hard because of how young I look. But since I knew that, I worked strategically in a way that showed that I had wisdom. When the job got tough, I vented to my superiors appropriately, I didn’t drag anyone’s name into the mix. When someone hurt me in the ministry, I took it to God before I took it to anyone else. I never told parents how to parent, but asked them how I could help their family. I let wisdom be my go-to no matter what. I wanted to set the example, even when it wasn’t being asked to be set.

I guarded my heart in the worst of times, not because I’m awesome, but because I knew that my youthfulness paints more targets on my ministry. Folks I’ve made plenty of mistakes, so don’t think I’m perfect. Yet even when I operated by the book, people rejected my voice in the conversation. Paul promises that you will be despised, but he also encourages us to not let it be a roadblock to our ministries.

One month ago I was counseling a family and after pointing a parent to some scripture, the parent looked at me and said this verbatim, “I understand the bible says that, but I’m not going to follow it because you’re 26 and I’m 48.” I was despised for my youth. The wisdom that the Gospel offers to people was rejected because I’m 26? This felt like a huge roadblock. But one week later I got a call from one of my ruling elders. The phone conversation ended like this: “ I’ve been watching you for the past year, and I wish I could have had someone like you leading me when I was in my 20s. I just want you to know that I believe in your mission, because I’ve seen how you live when life was rough and when people acted poorly. Whatever your next idea is, my answer is yes. It doesn’t matter if its a $5 idea or a $5000 dollar idea. My answer is yes.”

I never want to come off as being boastful, but I had to share that last conversation. Ministry is rough, especially when you look like you’re a teenager leading teens. But when you live a life that is worthy of your calling, people will start to notice. When every aspect of your life shows the Gospel, people will feel convicted.

To all you Baby-Faced pastors and youth workers, know this: You are not alone. The struggle is real! But you are making a huge impact on the kingdom of God. You are reaching an audience that no other person can reach. I know it may seem hopeless at times, but someone is always watching you, and they are silently being inspired by the way you live. I want to leave you with this final verse. Spend a few minutes meditating on this:

I therefore, a prisoner for the Lord, urge you to walk in a manner worthy of the calling to which you have been called, with all humility and gentleness, with patience, bearing with one another in love, eager to maintain the unity of the Spirit in the bond of peace. Hebrews 4:1-3

Resources for your next gathering

Plan your youth ministry teaching calendar

Connect your teaching plan with the rhythm of your ministry year.

Essentials — Youth Pastor Co

For a future teaching series, explore four weeks on believing, belonging, becoming, and building into others.