How to Have Difficult Conversations with Staff and Volunteers
By Austin Walker
Restored from the YouthMin archive.

Session by Jim Wideman
We all have situations in life where we deal with people we don’t like, who give us difficulty, etc.
YOUR ROLE AS A LEADER
1 Peter 5:2-3. // 4 main duties/purposed of a shepherd
FEED THEM . We must realized as ministers we help feed the people we are in charge of. It prepares them for the next level. Most of us spend the majority of our time learning how to be better feeders.
CAREGIVER . Giving care to people, sometimes it involves helping them get out of hurtful things they’re doing. We look to make sure they’re doing the things they need to do.
OVERSEEING . If you are busy just teaching and looking at their care, you can’t walk around and see what’s going on in ministry. Walk around. It’s hard for us to see it as a first time visitor. Sneak up on folks. You are more valuable to your leaders as a leader of leaders as opposed to just a teacher of kids. Part of your job is making sure stuff gets done, which means sometimes having difficult conversations.
BE AN EXAMPLE . Are you modeling how things need to get done? A big part of what you model is how they can represent you. If you have a difficult conversation, sometimes you need a witness, and you bring someone who can see how you model having those conversations. Two birds, one stone. Even when you have “captains of 10″ etc, YOU still have to handle the difficult situations. Part of being an example is showing people how to handle these.
You have to evaluate these areas in your life as a leader.
sometimes that means bragging on folks.
sometimes that means corrections.
just because it’s not fun doesn’t mean it’s not needed
ATTITUDE
To have difficult conversations, you need to check your attitude. Are they already guilty in your mind before you talk to them?
Sometimes you don’t like stuff, but to operate in grace and mercy, you have to adjust your thinking to make sure your thinking lines up with what God’s word says.
Having the conversations
1. UNDERSTAND YOURSELF
How do you naturally view situations? Half full vs. Half empty.
There’s a natural lens we all look through. What makes you who you are!
We all put on the same corrective lenses (Word of God) so we see correctly.
“Take every thought captive.” Sometimes that’s hard, messy, physical. But we have to make our thoughts obedient and lines up to the Word.
When you find yourself in a certain environment you have to speak their language. Know the language they speak. If it’s a detail person, speak that. If it’s a vision person, speak that. If it’s a fact guy, speak that.
Your children have different personalities, thus warrant different parenting nuances. Same concept in leading people.
Identify your strengths and weaknesses going in.
Check your heart on a regular basis.
2. JESUS WAS CONFRONTATIONAL
“I’m not going to be confrontational.” Jesus was! He wasn’t mean, but there was a time to be confrontational.
Sometimes truth is needed in a confrontational way.
Parents confront their children for their betterment without hesitation…BECAUSE YOU LOVE THEM.
Are you showing your volunteers that you don’t love them because you avoid confrontation?
As you lead, the quicker you can take off one hat and put on the appropriate hat in the same situation, the more effective you’ll be in leading the outcome. Times you come in and think of them as family, which is great, but you have to be able to confront.
RULES TO LIVE BY
ESTABLISH THE HABBIT OF CATCHING PEOPLE DOING THINGS RIGHT. People will listen to the correction a little better because you have a habit of noticing the good. If all you say is negative, that’s bad leadership. Write thank you notes ever week.
ESTABLISH COACHES OR MIDDLE MANAGEMENT AND LET THEM HELP YOU IN MIDDLE MANAGEMENT . The larger the team, there are coordinators but also position coaches. Have people help you coach people. You handle the hard things, but allow others to represent you in others.
PRACTICE MAKING SMALL CORRECTIONS AND SUGGESTIONS SANDWICHED BETWEEN COMPLIMENTS AND ENCOURAGEMENT.
MAKE IT A MATTER OF PRAYER. Pray before you go into a situation like this! Jesus prayed folks in, out, up, down, he went away to pray, he prayed before, he prayed after. Sometimes He took folks with Him, sometimes He didn’t.
ASK FOR HELP. The voice of God is always the voice of wisdom. Seek council.
MAKE SURE WHAT YOU’RE TRYING TO DO FITS . Understand your church’s philosophy and procedures, so if you have to take necessary actions, you know how it’s done and what the precedent is.
WHEN YOU HAVE THE CONVERSATION IS JUST AS IMPORTANT AS HOW YOU SAY IT. The same goes for the location. Don’t have them in a hallway.
HOW YOU DO THINGS. Sometimes that requires being solo, sometimes you need a witness. Does their spouse need to be there? Are they a volunteer or staff? For staff, know your state HR laws.
PAPER TRAIL. Especially if it’s an HR issue. Start writing the conversations down. Do your due diligence in protecting the file, but keep a record.
BEST WAY TO START IS “I KNOW YOU WANT WHAT’S BEST” . Being positive is good. ”I know the kind of parent you are, and I knew you would want to know this…” Show that you believe in them.
LOOK THEM IN THE EYES WHEN YOU TALK TO THEM.
BE HUMBLE AND CARING. I can take some difficult correction if I KNOW they really care (see #1). Ephesians 4:32
HAVE WHAT YOU’RE GOING TO SAY PLANNED OUT. It’s okay to go into a meeting with notes.
BE HONEST. TO THE POINT.
LET THEM KNOW WHAT NEEDS TO CHANGE. Offer an action plan to fix it. ”Here’s why you are terrible, get out of my office” won’t work. ”What if we did this…” Make an action plan so they know the next steps. Get them a book, pair them with someone, something to walk through it with them.
SET A DEADLINE FOR CHANGE. You wouldn’t do your taxes if there wasn’t one. They probably won’t be super thrilled about it, so set a deadline so they’ll be intentional.
OFFER TO WALK WITH THEM IF AT ALL POSSIBLE THAT YOU CAN . Having someone alongside in a difficult thing is always helpful.
LISTEN TO THEM.
STICK TO YOUR GUNS, BUT REAFFIRM YOUR LOVE FOR THEM.
END WITH THANKS AND A POSITIVE. ”Thanks for coming in today” at the very least.
FOLLOW UP WITH A NOTE OR A PHONE CALL. A little bit of PR goes a long way. Check on the people, see how they’re doing. Reenforce your love for them.
NOTICE THEIR EFFORTS FOR CHANGE . Catch them doing it right to reenforce that.
DON’T ACT PHONY AROUND THEM. Don’t treat them differently after that conversation. They’re waiting to see how you’ll act around them now.
DON’T PUT IT OFF TOO LONG. You’ll miss your opportunity for effective change if you wait until it doesn’t matter.
LET THE PUNISHMENT FIT THE CRIME.
BE CONSISTENT. Consistency is what makes you a great leader. Don’t show favoritism.
WHAT IF THEY DON’T CHANGE? Follow the appropriate next step. Volunteers and staff must be handled differently legally. You are not choosing to discipline people because you’re bored, you’re choosing to discipline them because of their decisions. You’re just enforcing actions they chose to do or not to do. The best advice is this: “Look for any opportunity to show mercy when dealing with others, because you may find yourself dealing with others as well”
AUSTIN’S ACTION POINT: I need to do better about setting out clear expectations. It’s hard to hold people accountable to expectations only you’re aware of.
Austin Walker
Student Pastor at Fellowship Bible Church (www.fellowshiponline.com) in Cabot, AR. Randomly posts at http://austinjwalker.wordpress.com
More Posts - Website